As of September 2026, the housing market hasn’t rebounded—it’s still soft. The NAHB/Wells Fargo Housing Market Index fell to 32 in September, marking well over a year of readings below the neutral 50 mark.¹ That’s a sharp contrast to 2020, when builder confidence hit a record high of 78 during an earlier rebound. Understanding both periods helps explain what a genuine housing market recovery actually requires.
Builder Confidence Today: Where the Housing Market Index Stands
The Housing Market Index (HMI), produced monthly by the National Association of Home Builders (NAHB), measures builder sentiment on a scale where readings above 50 indicate a positive outlook and readings below 50 signal caution.
Here’s where builder confidence has stood through 2026:
- April: 34
- May: 37
- June: 35–36
- July: 34
- September: 32¹
Sentiment has now stayed below 40 for more than a year—one of the longest such stretches since the 2011–2012 foreclosure crisis.¹
What’s Driving the Current Housing Market Slowdown
Several factors are keeping builder confidence—and buyer demand—subdued:
- Elevated mortgage rates, which continue to price out prospective buyers
- Rising material and land costs, squeezing builder margins
- Persistent affordability challenges, keeping many buyers on the sidelines
- A national housing shortage of an estimated 1.2 million homes, adding long-term pressure to supply¹
Builders are responding directly: 38% cut prices in September, with the average cut holding at 6% for six straight months, and 66% of builders reported using sales incentives to attract buyers.¹
Looking Back: The 2020 Housing Market Rebound as a Case Study
The current slowdown looks very different from the housing market’s last major swing. In April 2020, builder confidence sank to just 30 as the pandemic swept the nation. By August of that year, it had rocketed to 78—matching the previous all-time record set in December 1998.²
That rebound was driven largely by record-low mortgage rates and a shift in what buyers wanted from a home. As remote work and remote learning took hold, priorities shifted toward home offices, garages, and larger backyards.²
For more on how households have invested in their living spaces over time, see Home Improvements Trending Higher.
Why Housing Market Trends Matter for the Broader Economy
Housing isn’t an isolated sector—it can contribute up to 18% of U.S. Gross Domestic Product (GDP), making it one of the clearest barometers of overall economic health.³ Whether the Housing Market Index is climbing or falling, it tends to reflect—and influence—broader economic conditions like employment, consumer confidence, and financing availability.
What Would It Take for a Real Housing Market Recovery?
Based on current conditions, a meaningful housing market recovery would likely require:
- Lower mortgage rates, easing affordability pressure for buyers
- Reduced material and labor costs, giving builders room to price homes more competitively
- Progress on the housing shortage, increasing available inventory over time
Until those conditions shift, builders are likely to keep relying on price cuts and incentives rather than seeing demand rebound on its own.
Making Your Biggest Financial Decision
Buying a home remains one of the largest financial commitments most people make—and today’s mix of price cuts, incentives, and elevated rates creates a very different calculus than in past markets.
For guidance on how real estate decisions fit into your broader financial goals, see Financial Advice for Retirement Planning for Florida Retirees and Best Retirement Portfolios for a Secure Future.
If you’re considering buying a home or planning a move, we’d love to help guide your decisions and provide personalized advice to match your goals.
FAQ: Housing Market Rebound and Builder Confidence
Is the housing market rebounding in 2026?
Not currently. As of September 2026, the Housing Market Index sits at 32—well below the neutral 50 mark—reflecting more than a year of soft builder sentiment driven by elevated mortgage rates and affordability challenges.
What is the Housing Market Index (HMI)?
The HMI is a monthly gauge from the National Association of Home Builders that measures builder sentiment on new single-family home sales. A reading above 50 indicates a positive outlook; below 50 signals caution.
What caused the 2020 housing market rebound?
Builder confidence rebounded from 30 to a record 78 in 2020, driven by record-low mortgage rates and a pandemic-era shift in buyer priorities toward home offices, garages, and larger backyards.
What’s currently holding back a housing market recovery?
Elevated mortgage rates, rising material and land costs, and a national shortage of an estimated 1.2 million homes are the main factors keeping builder confidence and buyer demand subdued.
How does the housing market affect the broader economy?
Housing can account for up to 18% of U.S. GDP, making it a key indicator of overall economic health. Shifts in builder confidence often mirror—and can influence—broader economic trends.
- NAHB.com, September 2026
- CNBC.com / MarketWatch.com, August 2020
- NAHB.com, 2020
Important Investment Information
Investing involves risk, and the return and principal value of investments fluctuate as market conditions change. Consequently, when you sell, your investments may be worth more or less than their original cost. Additionally, past performance does not guarantee future results.
The Dow Jones Industrial Average is an unmanaged index that represents large-capitalization companies in the U.S. stock market. Similarly, the S&P 500 Composite Index is an unmanaged group of securities considered representative of the stock market in general. The Nasdaq Composite tracks common stocks and similar securities listed on the Nasdaq stock market, serving as a broad indicator of the performance of technology and growth companies.
We develop this content from sources we believe provide accurate information. However, this material does not constitute tax or legal advice. Therefore, you should consult qualified legal or tax professionals for guidance specific to your situation.
FMG Suite produced this material to provide information on topics that may interest you. FMG Suite, LLC does not affiliate with the named representative, broker-dealer, or any state- or SEC-registered investment advisory firm. Finally, the opinions expressed in this material serve general informational purposes only and should not be considered a solicitation to buy or sell any security.
