What Is a Nonqualified Deferred Compensation Plan?
What Is a Nonqualified Deferred Compensation (NQDC) Plan?
A nonqualified deferred compensation (NQDC) plan is an arrangement between an employer and an employee to defer payment of currently earned compensation to a future date — typically retirement.
Unlike qualified retirement plans, NQDC plans don’t come with the same tax-favored benefits. But they also don’t have to comply with the participation, vesting, funding, distribution, and reporting rules that Internal Revenue Code (IRC) Section 401(a) and the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) impose on qualified plans.
Because most NQDC plans fall outside those requirements, they’re a highly flexible form of compensation. An employer can:
- Tailor benefit amounts, payment terms, and conditions to fit the needs of specific employees
- Cover any group of employees without regard to nondiscrimination rules
- Provide unlimited benefits
- Offer different benefit amounts under different terms to different employees
The main advantage for employees is tax deferral. Unlike cash compensation — which the IRS taxes in the year it’s earned — employees can defer taxation on NQDC plan benefits until they’re actually received.
Caution: To achieve this tax deferral, an NQDC plan must either be “unfunded,” or if “funded,” the benefits must be nontransferable and subject to a substantial risk of forfeiture.
Example: Hal agrees to pay his employee Mark a $100,000 annual salary, plus an additional $10,000 for every year Mark works for him, payable at Mark’s retirement. That additional $10,000-per-year arrangement is a basic form of nonqualified deferred compensation.
Tip: How much ERISA applies to an NQDC plan depends on the plan type and its funding status. Most NQDC plans are designed to avoid nearly all ERISA requirements by remaining unfunded and limiting participation to a “select group of management or highly compensated employees” — commonly called a top-hat plan.
Tip: One exception is the “excess benefit plan,” which can be funded and still avoid most ERISA requirements (more on this below).
Caution: The SEC has occasionally taken the position that NQDC plans may require registration under the Securities Act of 1933, though many exceptions apply. Public companies may also have SEC or shareholder reporting obligations. Consult a securities professional for specifics.
Funded vs. Unfunded NQDC Plans: What’s the Difference?
NQDC plans fall into two categories — funded and unfunded — and understanding the technical difference matters, because it determines both the tax and ERISA consequences of the plan.
Unfunded plans are far more common because they preserve tax deferral while avoiding nearly all of ERISA’s requirements. Funded plans must generally comply with ERISA and offer more limited deferral opportunities.
| Plan Type | Coverage | Taxation of Benefits | ERISA | Creditor Protection |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Unfunded (or informally funded) | Limited to a select group of management or highly compensated employees | Generally taxed when paid | Very limited application | Benefits remain subject to the employer’s creditors |
| Funded | Any employee may be covered | Generally taxed when vested* | ERISA applies** | Benefits are generally protected from the employer’s creditors** |
Special rules apply to excess benefit plans, church plans, and plans maintained by governmental or tax-exempt employers.
*Employee secular trusts may not be covered by ERISA — creditor protection may then depend on state law.
When Is an NQDC Plan Considered “Funded”?
Neither ERISA nor the Internal Revenue Code formally defines “funding.” The concept has instead been shaped by court decisions and guidance from the Department of Labor (DOL) and IRS.
Generally, a plan is funded if assets have been irrevocably and unconditionally set aside with a third party (such as a trust or escrow account) and those assets are beyond the reach of both the employer and its general creditors. In other words, if participants are guaranteed to receive their benefits, the plan is funded. This is also called “formal funding,” and the most common vehicle for it is the secular trust.
A plan is unfunded when either no assets have been set aside (a “pay as you go” plan) or assets have been set aside but remain subject to the employer’s general creditors (an “informally funded” plan). In an unfunded plan, employees are relying solely on the employer’s unsecured promise to pay. To avoid ERISA, participation must be limited to a select group of management or highly compensated employees — again, a top-hat plan.
Caution: Funding may also be triggered if employees have legal rights to specific set-aside assets that are superior to the employer’s general creditors, or if employee communications suggest their benefits are secured by specific assets. Careful plan drafting and consultation with a pension professional can help avoid this.
Tip: There are fine distinctions between funding for tax purposes and funding for ERISA purposes, but in nearly all cases, a plan considered funded for one purpose is considered funded for the other.
What Is an Informally Funded Plan?
Most employers want to avoid formally funding an NQDC plan (to preserve ERISA exemption and tax deferral), but still want to set aside assets to help meet future benefit obligations. This is called informal funding.
Because the assets remain part of the employer’s general assets — reachable by creditors — informally funded plans are still considered unfunded. Informal funding lets an employer match assets to future liabilities and gives employees some added confidence that benefits will be paid. The two most common informal funding methods are corporate-owned life insurance (COLI) and the rabbi trust.
Example: Widget Corporation sets up a rabbi trust — an IRS-approved irrevocable grantor trust — to informally fund an NQDC plan for its executives. Even though the assets are earmarked for plan participants, they must remain subject to the claims of Widget’s general creditors. From an ERISA standpoint, the plan is still considered unfunded.
Why Would an Employer Establish a Funded Plan?
An employer might choose a funded plan when benefit security is the employee’s primary concern. In an unfunded plan, set-aside assets remain exposed to the employer’s creditors — which can make employees wary that deferred compensation won’t be paid if the employer has a change of heart, changes ownership, faces financial trouble, or enters bankruptcy.
Funded plans, by contrast, are generally protected from the employer’s creditors, offering employees stronger assurance of payment. An employer might also use a funded plan to provide benefits to an employee who doesn’t qualify as part of the top-hat group.
NQDC Plan Tax Treatment
Employee Tax Treatment: Unfunded Plans
In most cases, an employee has no income tax consequences until benefits are actually paid from the plan — at which point the full amount is included in gross income. There are exceptions, however, where the IRS may tax contributions earlier.
Constructive receipt doctrine. Under this doctrine, the IRS can tax an employee before funds are received if those funds are credited to the employee’s account, set aside, or otherwise made available without substantial restrictions. In short, once funds are earned and available, the employee must report the income — even if they’ve chosen not to accept payment yet.
Constructive receipt is most relevant to plans that let employees elect to defer compensation or elect to receive previously deferred amounts. To avoid constructive receipt, an employee generally must make the deferral election before the year the compensation is earned, and generally can’t have any right to accelerate payment ahead of the plan’s terms.
IRC Section 409A. Section 409A sets specific rules on deferral elections, distributions, and funding that apply to most NQDC plans, largely codifying the constructive receipt principles above. If a plan fails to follow Section 409A, affected participants’ NQDC benefits — for that year and all prior years — can become immediately taxable, plus penalties and interest. Following Section 409A deferred compensation rules is essential when establishing any NQDC plan.
Employee Tax Treatment: Funded Plans
In a funded plan, an employee must generally include employer contributions in gross income in the year they’re made — or, if later, the year they vest (i.e., no longer subject to a substantial risk of forfeiture). The exact tax consequences depend on the funding vehicle used.
Caution: Employees may be taxed on employer contributions — and investment earnings — before they actually receive the funds. Employers can offset this with a cash bonus to cover the tax liability, or, if the plan uses a secular trust, the employee may take a distribution from the trust to pay the taxes.
Tip: A funded plan only provides tax deferral if the employee’s benefit is subject to a substantial risk of forfeiture. An unfunded plan, by contrast, can provide tax deferral even when the benefit is fully vested.
Tip: If a change in control triggers accelerated vesting or distribution, the “golden parachute” rules under IRC Section 280G may apply.
Employer Tax Treatment
Unfunded plans. The employer generally receives a tax deduction in the same year the corresponding amount is included in the employee’s gross income — meaning the deduction typically arrives in the year benefits are actually paid, including any earnings. If the employer sets aside funds for future benefits (for example, in a rabbi trust), it must pay income tax on any earnings those funds generate. This is one reason NQDC plans are often informally funded with corporate-owned life insurance: policy cash value growth generally isn’t subject to current income tax (unless AMT rules apply).
Funded plans. The employer is generally entitled to a deduction in the year the contribution is included in the employee’s gross income — the year of contribution, or if later, the year of vesting. Employers generally can’t deduct earnings on funded-plan contributions.
Caution: To deduct contributions to a plan funded with an employer secular trust, separate accounts may need to be maintained for each participating employee. A deduction is only permitted to the extent the contribution is reasonable in amount and an ordinary, necessary business expense. Publicly held companies also can’t deduct total compensation over $1 million in a year for certain executives.
Top-Hat Plans
Because most NQDC plans are unfunded to preserve tax deferral while avoiding ERISA’s more burdensome requirements, they must be limited to a select group of management or highly compensated employees. This structure — the most common type of NQDC plan — is known as a top-hat plan.
What Constitutes a “Select Group of Management or Highly Compensated Employees”?
There’s no formal legal definition, but it generally refers to a small percentage of employees who hold key management roles or earn substantially more than the rest of the workforce. Courts and the DOL have weighed factors such as:
- The number of employees covered under the plan versus the total workforce
- The average salary of the select group versus other employees
- The average salary of the select group versus all management or highly compensated employees
- The salary range within the select group
The DOL has indicated the phrase applies to employees who, by position or compensation, can influence the design or operation of the plan — essentially, employees positioned to negotiate their own compensation. Courts have generally taken a more liberal view than the DOL on this point.
ERISA Considerations for Top-Hat Plans
For an unfunded top-hat plan, only two ERISA requirements typically apply:
- DOL notification. The plan administrator (typically the employer) must file a one-page letter with the DOL within 120 days of the plan’s inception, listing the company’s name, address, and employer identification number, the number of top-hat plans maintained, participant counts, and a statement that the plan exists primarily to provide deferred compensation to a select group of management or highly compensated employees. Missing this deadline subjects the plan to ERISA’s full reporting and disclosure requirements.
- Claims procedures. Participants must be informed of the ERISA claims procedures that apply to the plan, typically described in the plan document.
A funded plan, by contrast, must generally comply with ERISA in full — including its rules on administration, reporting, disclosure, participation, vesting, funding, and fiduciary duties.
Caution: It’s unclear whether ERISA applies to plans funded with an employee secular trust, since ERISA applies only to plans established by an employer, and secular trusts are treated as employee-created for tax purposes.
Tip: ERISA doesn’t apply to governmental and most church plans, plans covering only non-employees (such as company directors), plans covering only partners and their spouses, or plans covering only a sole proprietor and spouse.
Social Security Tax (FICA and FUTA) and NQDC Plans
Social Security tax includes several components: FICA (old age and disability), Medicare (hospital insurance), and FUTA (unemployment). Both FICA and FUTA can apply currently to amounts deferred into an NQDC plan, though the impact is often smaller than expected.
FUTA applies only to a limited portion of compensation, and most employees deferring income into an NQDC plan already exceed the annual Social Security wage base ($184,500 for 2026). Compensation above that wage base is generally subject only to the 1.45% Medicare tax, paid by both employer and employee.
Caution: FICA and FUTA rules as applied to NQDC plans are complex — consult a tax professional for guidance specific to your plan.
Who Can Adopt a Nonqualified Deferred Compensation Plan?
Many types of entities can adopt an NQDC plan, but they’re best suited to financially sound businesses with a reasonable expectation of continued profitability. Because NQDC plans are less expensive to implement than qualified plans, they can also be an attractive option for newer businesses with growth potential but limited cash resources — including many closely held businesses here in Southwest Florida.
Business Owners
For business owners, NQDC plans work best for regular (C) corporations. Owners of S corporations or unincorporated entities (partnerships, sole proprietorships) generally can’t defer taxes on their own share of business income. However, S corporations and unincorporated businesses can still adopt NQDC plans for employees who have no ownership stake.
Caution: Plans covering controlling shareholders may draw IRS scrutiny under the constructive receipt doctrine, given the shareholder’s control over the corporate employer.
Government and Tax-Exempt Organizations
Governmental and tax-exempt organizations can adopt NQDC plans, but must follow IRC Section 457, which limits the amount and timing of payouts and, in some cases, may require current taxation on the present value of an employee’s deferred compensation rights.
Advantages of a Nonqualified Deferred Compensation Plan
Supplements qualified plan benefits. Qualified plans carry strict contribution and benefit limits that particularly affect highly paid executives. For 2026, for example:
- Combined employer and employee contributions to a defined contribution plan are capped at the lesser of $72,000 or 100% of compensation
- Employees 50+ can contribute an additional $8,000 catch-up ($11,250 for those age 60–63)
- Maximum annual compensation considered for these calculations is $360,000
- Maximum employee salary deferral into a 401(k) is $24,500, plus catch-up contributions
An NQDC plan for executives can supplement these qualified benefits by providing deferred compensation above and beyond these caps.
Example: Richard and Mary both work at BCD Corporation and participate in a defined benefit plan offering 50% of salary as a benefit. Richard earns $360,000, so his plan formula would suggest a $180,000 benefit — but because $360,000 is also the maximum compensation the plan can factor in, his benefit calculation can’t exceed that same cap, limiting what he actually receives relative to his true salary. Mary earns $100,000, well under the cap, so she receives the full 50% the plan formula promises. Richard is disadvantaged by the compensation limit; Mary isn’t.
Simpler and less costly than a qualified plan. Qualified plans must follow complex IRS and ERISA rules, making them more expensive to implement and maintain. An NQDC plan lets an employer offer tax-deferred retirement benefits to key employees without those administrative costs.
Can be offered selectively. Qualified plans must meet nondiscrimination and participation requirements. NQDC plans aren’t bound by these rules, so an employer can extend the benefit to just a few — or even one — highly compensated employee, with no obligation to cover anyone else.
Can provide unlimited benefits, subject to the reasonable-compensation requirement for deductibility.
Gives the employer control over timing. Because ERISA’s vesting rules don’t apply to unfunded NQDC plans, employers have flexibility in setting the conditions and timing for when benefits become payable.
Helps attract and retain key employees. A well-designed NQDC plan — offered in addition to or instead of a qualified plan — can be a meaningful incentive for recruiting and retaining executives and other key personnel.
Disadvantages of a Nonqualified Deferred Compensation Plan
Employee controls the timing of the employer’s deduction. The employer generally can’t deduct a contribution until the year the employee actually receives income from the plan — often years later, especially if the employee defers until retirement.
Less security for employees. Participants typically must rely on the employer’s unsecured promise to pay (unless the plan is formally funded). Most ERISA protections — participation, vesting, fiduciary responsibility, and funding standards — don’t apply.
Limited value for partnerships, sole proprietorships, and S corporations. These entities can establish plans for key employees, but the owners themselves get little benefit, since their share of business income is taxed to them immediately regardless of deferral.
Generally more costly to the employer than paying compensation currently. Because the employer’s deduction is deferred along with the payment — and the deferred amount typically grows with interest or investment earnings — the employer’s net after-tax cost is usually higher than if the compensation had simply been paid and deducted when earned. This added cost should factor into any NQDC plan design.
How Does a Nonqualified Deferred Compensation Plan Work?
How does a nonqualified deferred compensation plan work in practice? It depends on the plan type, the specific agreement, and how (or whether) it’s funded.
In a typical unfunded top-hat plan, the employer pays benefits from its general assets as they come due. The employee is relying entirely on the employer’s unfunded promise and bears the risk that benefits may not ultimately be paid. Employers can add some assurance by informally funding the plan with a rabbi trust or corporate-owned life insurance — but those assets must still remain subject to the employer’s general creditors, meaning employees could lose their benefits in the event of the employer’s insolvency or bankruptcy. This is one of the central trade-offs of an unfunded plan from the employee’s perspective.
Caution: Top-hat plans must comply with IRC Section 409A’s rules governing deferral elections, distributions, and funding.
Employee Elective Salary and Bonus Deferrals
A top-hat plan can allow participants to elect to defer part of their salary and/or bonus — often called an “elective” plan, as opposed to a “nonelective” plan funded entirely by the employer. Elections generally must be made in writing before the tax year in which the compensation is earned (bonus deferral elections tied to a performance period of at least 12 months may be made up to six months before the period ends). Employees typically must also elect the timing and form of payment at the same time. Unlike a qualified plan, a top-hat plan may allow deferral of up to 100% of compensation, and participants are generally fully vested in their own deferrals and related earnings.
Discretionary Employer Contributions
Top-hat plans can also include employer contributions, in addition to or instead of employee deferrals. These are typically discretionary — the employer isn’t required to contribute in any given year — and often subject to vesting conditions, such as forfeiture if the employee doesn’t remain with the company for a set number of years or leaves before a specified age.
Accounting and Investment Control
Unfunded NQDC plans generally take one of two forms:
- Defined benefit plans, which pay a pension-like benefit based on years of service and/or final average pay, often supplementing what a qualified pension plan provides
- Individual account (defined contribution) plans, where the benefit depends on the value of a bookkeeping account credited with deferrals, employer contributions, and “hypothetical” or “notional” investment earnings
Employees can often “direct” how their individual account is notionally invested, but the employer (or trustee, in a rabbi trust arrangement) isn’t obligated to actually invest assets that way — the investment election simply determines how much hypothetical earning gets credited. If the employer were obligated to actually invest as directed, the IRS has suggested this level of “dominion and control” could trigger immediate taxation under constructive receipt or economic benefit principles.
Top-Hat Plans That Supplement Qualified Plan Benefits (SERPs)
A common nonelective top-hat plan design provides a post-retirement benefit that supplements an employee’s qualified plan and Social Security benefits — commonly known as a supplemental executive retirement plan (SERP). A SERP might calculate a target pension benefit, then subtract what the employee actually receives from qualified plans and Social Security, with the difference paid by the employer as the NQDC benefit. These plans often include vesting provisions, sometimes tied to the employer’s qualified plan vesting schedule.
Payment of Benefits
Employers can structure a top-hat plan to pay benefits upon retirement, separation from service, disability, death, an unforeseen emergency, or a specified date — as a lump sum or in a series of payments (life annuities or fixed terms, such as 5 or 10 years, are common). Because most ERISA requirements don’t apply to a properly structured plan, employers have flexibility in setting vesting schedules and forfeiture conditions. Any distribution provisions must still satisfy IRC Section 409A.
Â
Types of Nonqualified Deferred Compensation Plans
Since an NQDC plan is essentially a contract between employer and employee, there’s a wide range of possible designs. The term “nonqualified deferred compensation” can also cover stock plans and severance arrangements such as golden parachutes. Plans established by government and tax-exempt organizations are governed by IRC Section 457 and are typically referred to as Section 457 plans.
The plan types below represent non-stock-based compensation deferral or supplemental arrangements — with the exception of excess benefit plans, nearly all are unfunded top-hat plans.
Deferral Plan
Provides deferred benefits in place of current compensation, a raise, or a bonus. A common example is the salary reduction plan, which lets employees defer income they could otherwise receive currently.
Supplemental Executive Retirement Plan (SERP)
A plan that supplements an employer’s qualified plan benefits, structured as either a defined benefit or defined contribution arrangement. The term is also sometimes used more broadly to describe any top-hat plan.
Wraparound 401(k) Plan
Also called a mirror or executive 401(k) plan, this design mimics the employer’s qualified 401(k) plan but allows deferrals beyond the qualified plan’s limits. An employee’s full intended deferral first flows into the nonqualified wraparound plan; once year-end discrimination testing on the 401(k) plan is complete, the maximum amount the employee is eligible to defer into the qualified plan is transferred there. This ensures the employee defers exactly what they intended while still maximizing their permitted 401(k) contribution.
Excess Benefit Plan
Designed solely to provide benefits above the limits IRC Section 415 places on qualified plans. For 2026, Section 415 caps defined contribution plan contributions at the lesser of $72,000 or 100% of pay, and defined benefit plan benefits at the lesser of $290,000 or 100% of final three-year average pay. Unlike most NQDC plans, an unfunded excess benefit plan is entirely exempt from ERISA, and even a funded one is exempt from most ERISA requirements. Excess benefit plans also don’t need to be limited to a top-hat group, though in practice, only highly compensated employees are typically affected by the Section 415 limits.
Ways to Secure NQDC Plan Benefits
Employees often worry that promised NQDC benefits won’t ultimately be paid — due to a change of heart, a change in control, financial trouble, or bankruptcy. Employers have several options for providing varying degrees of assurance:
- Secular trusts
- Secular annuities
- Rabbi trusts
- Rabbicular trusts
- Corporate-owned life insurance (COLI)
- Split-dollar life insurance
- Surety bonds and indemnity insurance
Frequently Asked QuestionsÂ
What is a nonqualified deferred compensation plan?
A nonqualified deferred compensation (NQDC) plan is an agreement where an employer defers part of an employee’s compensation to a future date, typically retirement, outside the rules that govern qualified retirement plans like 401(k)s.
How does a nonqualified deferred compensation plan work?
An employer and employee agree to defer part of the employee’s compensation. In an unfunded (top-hat) plan, benefits are paid from the employer’s general assets when due, and the employee relies on the employer’s unsecured promise to pay. Funded plans set assets aside in a way that offers more security but carries different tax and ERISA consequences.
What is the tax treatment of a NQDC plan?
In an unfunded plan, the employee generally isn’t taxed until benefits are actually paid, provided the plan follows IRC Section 409A. In a funded plan, the employee is generally taxed when contributions are made or vested, whichever is later. Employers generally deduct the expense in the same year it’s taxed to the employee.
What is a top-hat plan?
A top-hat plan is an unfunded NQDC plan limited to a select group of management or highly compensated employees. This structure lets the plan avoid nearly all ERISA requirements while preserving tax deferral for participants.
What is a supplemental executive retirement plan (SERP)?
A SERP is a type of NQDC plan that provides executives with retirement benefits on top of what they receive from an employer’s qualified plan and Social Security, often used to make up for benefits lost to qualified plan limits.
What is the difference between a funded and unfunded NQDC plan?
An unfunded plan is a “pay as you go” or informally funded arrangement where assets remain subject to the employer’s creditors. A funded plan sets assets aside where employees are guaranteed to receive them, offering more security but triggering ERISA compliance and earlier taxation.
Who can set up a nonqualified deferred compensation plan?
NQDC plans work best for financially sound C corporations. Business owners in S corporations, partnerships, and sole proprietorships generally can’t defer their own income this way, though these entities can still offer NQDC plans to non-owner employees. Governmental and tax-exempt organizations can adopt plans under IRC Section 457.